David Einhorn is one of the most recognizable hedge fund managers of the modern era, a value investor who built Greenlight Capital into a multi-billion-dollar firm and became famous for a string of high-profile short bets against companies he believed were hiding the truth. His career has been a study in contrasts: brilliant early returns, public crusades against accounting he considered dishonest, and a long, difficult stretch where the market refused to cooperate.
Background
Einhorn graduated from Cornell University and started his Wall Street career in the early 1990s, working at firms including Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette. In 1996, at 27 years old, he founded Greenlight Capital with $900,000 raised from family and friends. The pitch was classic value investing: buy misunderstood or undervalued companies, hold concentrated positions, and do the homework yourself.
It worked spectacularly at first. Greenlight compounded at a very strong rate through its first decade-plus, drawing comparisons to the early years of the great value investors. Einhorn built a reputation as a meticulous analyst who read footnotes other managers skipped, and his investor letters became some of the most widely read in the industry.
The Allied Capital short
Einhorn’s first defining moment came in 2002, when he gave a now-legendary speech questioning the accounting of Allied Capital, a business development company. He argued that Allied was overstating the value of its investments and understating its problems. Allied’s management fought back hard, and the dispute dragged on for years, drawing in regulators and the press.
Einhorn later wrote about the episode in his book, Fooling Some of the People All of the Time, published in 2008. The book is part investment memoir and part indictment, arguing that Allied’s numbers were fiction and that the system, auditors, regulators, and the financial press, failed to stop it. The episode made Einhorn’s name: here was an investor willing to take on a public fight over accounting honesty, at real personal and professional cost.
The Lehman Brothers short
His most famous trade came a few years later. In 2008, as the financial crisis gathered force, Einhorn publicly disclosed that Greenlight was short Lehman Brothers, the investment bank. He argued that Lehman was understating its losses and using accounting maneuvers to hide the damage. That September, Lehman collapsed into the largest bankruptcy in U.S. history, and Einhorn’s call became one of the signature moments of the crisis.
The Lehman short cemented his image as the rare investor who saw the rot early and said so publicly. It also brought him unwanted attention. During the crisis, short sellers were blamed by some for driving banks into the ground, and Einhorn found himself defending the practice, arguing that short sellers expose problems rather than create them.
Investing style
Einhorn’s approach is value investing with a short-selling edge, in the tradition of Warren Buffett‘s emphasis on buying good businesses cheaply, but with an activist streak Buffett never had. Greenlight runs a concentrated long/short equity portfolio: a few dozen long positions in companies Einhorn believes are undervalued, paired with shorts against companies he believes are overvalued or dishonest.
The short book is what sets him apart. Most value investors simply avoid companies they dislike. Einhorn bets against them, and he does it loudly, publishing his theses and debating management in public. That willingness to fight has produced some of his best returns and some of his messiest episodes. In 2013 he took on Apple in a public campaign over its cash-hoarding, suing the company over a shareholder proposal. The confrontational style is part of the brand.
Later years and performance struggles
The second half of Einhorn’s career has been harder. Greenlight’s results have been uneven in recent years, with the fund trailing the S&P 500 over long stretches and suffering a notably painful 2018. Value investing broadly fell out of favor during the long bull market in growth stocks, and Einhorn’s concentrated, contrarian style, an advantage when he was right, amplified the damage when he was wrong.
Einhorn has been characteristically blunt about the struggle, telling investors in his letters that the market environment had become hostile to his approach and questioning whether value investing itself was broken. Some of his high-profile shorts moved against him for extended periods, a reminder that even correct theses can lose money for a long time before they pay off, or never pay off at all.
Outside the markets, Einhorn is known as a serious poker player, finishing third in the 2012 World Series of Poker’s Big One for One Drop tournament and donating the winnings to charity. It fits the profile: a game of incomplete information, played aggressively, with real money on the line.
Einhorn’s legacy is still being written, but its shape is clear. He showed that a small fund with deep research could take on giants, that short selling could be an act of market hygiene rather than vandalism, and that being right is not the same as being profitable. For investors, the lesson of his career may be the oldest one in value investing: the market can stay irrational longer than your patience, or your investors, can last.
You must be logged in to post a comment.