
Book Summary
Most investing books promise a system. Market Sense and Nonsense does the opposite. Published in 2012 by Wiley, it is Jack D. Schwager’s plain-spoken guide to what markets can and cannot do, built around the misconceptions that cost ordinary investors the most money. Schwager argues that much of what passes for market wisdom is either wrong or true only in a narrow sense, and that the damage comes not from ignorance but from confident-sounding half-truths: that past returns predict future ones, that diversification by itself protects you, and that a great track record proves skill.
The book works through the big topics one at a time: how markets actually function, what risk really means, how to judge a fund manager’s record, what hedge funds do and do not offer, and why the numbers investors rely on are so often misleading. Schwager leans on data and worked examples rather than anecdotes, and he is at his best when he shows how a plausible-sounding claim falls apart once you look at the arithmetic behind it.
It is not a book of stock picks or a trading manual, and Schwager does not pretend otherwise. The payoff is quieter: a reader who finishes it is harder to fool, by a fund pitch, a backtest, or their own memory of what worked last time. For an investor who manages their own money, that skepticism is worth more than another hot tip.
Buy Market Sense and Nonsense on Amazon
Who is Jack D. Schwager?
Schwager is best known as the author of Market Wizards, the 1989 collection of interviews with top traders that became one of the most widely read books in trading, and its sequel, New Market Wizards, published in 1992. The interviews made his reputation: he asked working traders how they actually made decisions, and let their contradictions stand instead of smoothing them into a system.
He studied economics, earning a bachelor’s degree from Brooklyn College and a master’s from Brown University, and spent decades writing about markets, first as an analyst and later as an author and fund manager. That combination, academic training plus long exposure to people who trade for a living, shapes the book’s approach: test the claim, look at the numbers, and distrust the story.
His later work on hedge funds and managed futures gave him a close view of how professional track records are built and marketed, which is exactly the subject this book takes apart. He writes as someone who has seen the sales pitch from the inside, and it shows.
Lessons From Market Sense and Nonsense
Past performance is a weak guide, and often a misleading one. Schwager shows how a strong multi-year record can be the product of luck, of taking hidden risks, or of a strategy that happened to fit one market regime. The lesson is not to ignore track records but to ask what produced them: how much risk was taken, how many other managers tried the same thing and vanished, and whether the conditions that made the record are still in place.
Diversification only works when the pieces are genuinely different. Holding twenty funds that all own the same large stocks is not diversification, and neither is spreading money across assets that all fall together in a crisis. The book’s test is simple: diversification has to come from return sources that behave differently from each other, especially when markets are stressed.
Risk is not volatility. A portfolio that swings up and down but never permanently loses capital is a different thing from one that can be wiped out by a single bad bet. Schwager’s emphasis is on the risk of permanent loss and on position sizing: the size of a bet matters more than being right about direction, because even a good idea can ruin you if it is too large when it goes wrong.
Be skeptical of backtests and of anyone selling certainty. A strategy tested on past data has usually been tuned, consciously or not, to fit that data, and the funds that survive to advertise their records are the lucky ones. Schwager’s rule of thumb is to discount any result that looks too clean, and to ask what the strategy would have looked like to someone trying it in real time, without knowing how the story ended.
Buy Market Sense and Nonsense on Amazon
Criticisms of the Book
The book is now more than a decade old, and some of its examples show it: the hedge fund world it describes has changed, fees have fallen, and some of the funds and managers it names have faded. The core arguments still hold, but a reader coming to it fresh may find the specifics dated and wish for an updated edition.
It also overlaps with Schwager’s interview books at points, and readers who already know the Market Wizards interviews will recognize some of the same themes. And it is a book about thinking, not doing: it will not tell you what to buy, and anyone looking for a step-by-step system will come away empty-handed.
Who is This Book For?
It is for the self-directed investor who has already read a few investing books and wants to know which of the standard advice actually holds up. Financial advisors and serious amateurs will get the most from it, since the chapters on judging managers and measuring performance speak directly to their daily work.
It is not for a beginner looking for a first portfolio, and it is not for anyone who wants stock picks. Start with something simpler if you have not yet built a basic portfolio; come back to this one when you are ready to question the numbers people show you.
Final Thoughts
Market Sense and Nonsense is one of the most useful books an investor can read, precisely because it does not flatter its reader. It replaces a set of comforting beliefs with a smaller set of tested ones, and the exchange is worth making. Few investing books make you harder to fool; this one does.
Read it alongside the Market Wizards interviews if you have not already. The interviews show what great traders do, and this book explains why so much of what everyone else says about markets is noise. Together they are a solid education in thinking about risk.









